The Widow’s Guide

Book Three · The House and the Things · Chapter 9

Who should get what?

“My daughter wants his watch. So does my son. What do I do?”

The short answer

Start with what the will says, if anything. For the rest, ask each person privately what matters to them before anyone takes anything, and use a fair way to choose when two people want the same thing.

Of the things that are yours to give, you can keep what you want first. Very little of this has to be settled soon, and none of it has to be settled by whoever asks first.

This chapter explains how things usually work in the United States. It is not legal, tax or financial advice, and the rules where you live may differ. Before you act on anything here, check it with one of the people named at the end of the chapter.

What to do

  1. Check the will, and any signed list with it, for named gifts.
  2. Ask the executor before giving away anything of value.
  3. Have anything that may be worth money appraised before it changes hands.
  4. Ask each person, privately, for the three things that matter most to them.
  5. Keep what you want first.
  6. Use a fair way to choose when two people want the same thing.
  7. Write down who got what, and when.

What can wait

Who can help

The executor can tell you what the will says about his belongings, and when they can leave the house. A probate or estate lawyer can explain the rest.

The ABA directory at americanbar.org/directories/lawyer-referral-directory finds your state and local bar associations, which run referral services. A helper, or a librarian at your public library, can look with you.

If the family can't agree, a private family or elder mediator can help. What each of these people actually does, at the back of this book, describes each one.

The rules, phone numbers and web addresses in this book were checked against the agencies’ own pages in October 2026. They change, so check anything you rely on with the office itself.

Cover of The House and the Things, Book 3 of The Widow’s Guide

From Book 3: The House and the Things

This page has the short answer and the closing lists from chapter 9. The full chapter explains, in plain words, what exists, what to ask, and who can answer. The book covers months 3 to 12.

About the book · Every question in the books

Hear when the next book is out

Five or six short emails a year at most, and a note when a new book is out. Each one is about something that tends to come up in the first two years. You can unsubscribe whenever you like.

For readers in the United States. We don’t sell or rent your address, and every email has a link to unsubscribe. How we handle your email